Trust and safety

Fake profiles and recruiter scams: how to spot them on professional networks

From:
, founder
Published:
Updated:

The short answer: be suspicious of any recruiter who offers a job before an interview, moves you off the platform, or asks for money or personal documents early. Check the person and the job through the company's own website, not the message. Fake profiles exist on every open network because anyone can sign up with any email and type any job title.

How big is the fake account problem?

Big, and platforms know it. LinkedIn's own reports show it removing more than 21 million fake accounts in the first half of 2019 alone, and blocking tens of millions more in later periods, mostly at sign-up. It says nearly all are stopped before members report them.

That is genuinely impressive defence, but scale works against it. If even a small fraction get through, that is a lot of fake recruiters. One person who has spent two years reporting fake job listings told reporters he had helped get nearly 60,000 removed, most of them from LinkedIn.

What are the signs of a fake recruiter or fake job?

No single sign is proof, but any of these should slow you down:

  • A job offer before any proper interview, or an interview held only by text.
  • Pressure to move to WhatsApp, Telegram or a personal email.
  • Money first: fees for training, equipment, visa processing or background checks.
  • Early requests for ID, bank details or your National Insurance number.
  • A salary that is too good for the role or your experience.
  • Vague company details, or a company name that is close to, but not quite, a real one.
  • An email address on a free provider, or on a domain that does not match the company's website.
  • A profile that looks thin: few connections, a short history, a stock or AI-looking photo, generic wording.

How can you spot a fake profile?

  • Check the history. Real profiles usually have a few jobs, some education and some activity over years. Fakes are often new.
  • Look at the photo. AI-generated faces can have odd earrings, blurred backgrounds or mismatched features.
  • Look at mutual connections. Fakes often connect with lots of people in one company or field to look credible.
  • Search the name with the company. Does the person appear on the company's website or anywhere else?
  • Read the writing. Generic, oddly formal or copied text is a hint.

What should you do if you think it's a scam?

  1. Stop. Do not send money, documents or one-time codes.
  2. Verify independently. Go to the company's own careers page or ring a number from its website, not one from the message.
  3. Report the profile on the platform.
  4. If you have lost money, contact your bank straight away. In the UK, report it to Action Fraud. Elsewhere, use your national fraud reporting service.
  5. Warn others in your field, without sharing anyone's personal details.

Why does verified sign-up help?

Most networks verify after the fact. They let anyone in, then try to catch the bad actors with machine learning and member reports. That is necessary at a billion-member scale, but it means a fake can work for a while before it is caught.

The alternative is to verify at the door. On Office Worker every member signs up with a work email address and has to enter a one-time code sent to it. Personal email providers such as Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook are not accepted. So every account is tied to a real organisation's email domain, which makes mass-produced fakes much harder.

It is not a magic shield. Someone could still misuse a real work address. But it raises the cost of faking a profile from nothing to something, and that is where most fakes give up. We explain the trade-offs in why we verify work emails.

What else keeps a professional network safe?

  • Never show email addresses publicly. On Office Worker, your email is never shown to other members.
  • Clear rules on what is allowed, published where anyone can read them.
  • Reasons for removals, so honest people can fix mistakes and appeal.
  • People in the loop. Automated checks catch most things, and a person reviews appeals.

For more on how we think about this, see the problem with modern networking sites.

Frequently asked questions

How common are fake profiles on LinkedIn?
LinkedIn reports removing or blocking tens of millions of fake accounts every six months, most of them at sign-up. In the first half of 2019 alone it removed more than 21 million. Some still get through, and those are the ones that reach members.
How can you tell if a LinkedIn recruiter is fake?
Warning signs include a job offer before any interview, pressure to move the chat to WhatsApp or Telegram, requests for money for training or equipment, requests for bank or ID details early on, a generic or AI-looking photo, few real connections, and an email address that doesn't match the company's domain.
What should I do if I think a profile is fake?
Do not send money, documents or codes. Check the company's real careers page or call them on a number from their own website. Report the profile on the platform, and if you have lost money, report it to Action Fraud in the UK or your national fraud service.
How does Office Worker deal with fake accounts?
Every member signs up with a work email address and must enter a one-time code sent to it. Personal email providers are not accepted, so each account is tied to a real organisation's email domain.

Sources

  1. LinkedIn community report
  2. Fortune: LinkedIn community standards violations (2019)
  3. TechSpot: fake job listings on LinkedIn
  4. CNBC: LinkedIn has a fake account problem it's trying to fix
  5. Action Fraud (UK)